首页|期刊导航|中国医学伦理学|人类基因组学研究的伦理治理探析

人类基因组学研究的伦理治理探析OA

Exploration of ethical governance in human genomics research

中文摘要英文摘要

随着人类基因组学技术与临床应用的快速发展,相关伦理问题引发了复杂的伦理治理挑战.这些挑战主要表现在数据开放共享下的新社会契约重构困境、群体数据集体属性与个体受益的道德冲突、精准医学下的结构性不平等问题、成本与收益失衡风险、优生学视角下的基因修改难题,以及代理同意与隐私保护问题等方面.国际治理实践表明,通过完善立法、发布倡议、强化伦理委员会及相应机构职能建设以及关切研究项目的伦理性等方式可以在一定程度上应对挑战,但仍存在法律滞后、倡议约束力不足等问题.与此同时,中国伦理治理工作虽然在顶层设计、国际交流与理论研究方面不断取得进展,但专门性立法和跨主体协作机制仍需完善.系统的伦理治理框架,需要建立前置监管体系,细化伦理审查、推进专门性立法及个案审批制度;完善基因组数据治理,健全云平台管理机制并推动数据分级治理;明确科研共同体责任,规范伦理审查并加强公众沟通以及构建政府、医疗卫生机构及其技术人员、公众与受试者协同配合的道德共同体等.通过人类基因组学研究的伦理治理体系建设,确保基因组学技术在造福人类的同时不逾越伦理底线,实现其研究与应用的安全性、公平性与可持续性.

With the rapid development of human genomics technologies and their clinical applications,relevant ethical issues have induced complex ethical governance challenges.These challenges mainly manifest in the dilemma of reconstructing a new social contract under data open sharing,the moral conflict between the collective nature of group data and individual benefits,the problem of structural inequality under precision medicine,the risk of imbalance between costs and benefits,the dilemma of genetic modification from a eugenic perspective,and the issue of proxy consent and privacy protection.International governance practices indicate that these challenges can be addressed to some extent by improving legislation,issuing initiatives,strengthening the functions of ethics committees and corresponding institutions,and focusing on the ethicality of research projects.However,issues such as legal lag and insufficient binding force of initiatives still exist.Meanwhile,although China's ethical governance work has made continuous progress in top-level design,international exchanges and theoretical research,specialized legislation and cross-subject collaboration mechanisms still necessitate improvement.A systematic ethical governance framework requires establishing a pre-regulatory system,refining ethical review,and promoting specialized legislation and case approval systems.It is also vital to improve genomic data governance,refine cloud platform management mechanisms,and promote hierarchical governance of the data.Furthermore,it is crucial to clarify the responsibilities of the scientific research community,standardize ethical review,strengthen public communication,and build a moral community with the collaborative cooperation of the government,medical and healthcare institutions and their technical personnel,the public,and research subjects.Through the construction of an ethical governance system for human genomics research,this ensures that genomics technologies benefit humanity without transgressing ethical boundaries,thereby achieving the safety,fairness,and sustainability of their research and application.

李德新;杨晨

山西大学科学技术哲学研究中心,山西 太原 030006山西大学科学技术哲学研究中心,山西 太原 030006

医药卫生

人类基因组学精准医疗伦理风险伦理治理

human genomicsprecision medicineethical riskethical governance

《中国医学伦理学》 2026 (5)

571-579,9

国家社会科学基金重大项目"爱思唯尔《科学哲学手册》翻译与研究"(18ZDA030)山西省高等学校青年学术带头人项目"基因组学及其应用的伦理问题研究"(2024Q002)

10.12026/j.issn.1001-8565.2026.05.03

评论