股骨髁内生软骨瘤及股骨颈转移瘤误诊原因剖析及早期鉴别诊断要点OA
Causes of misdiagnosis of femoral condyle enchondroma and femoral neck metastatic tumor and key points for early differential diagnosis
目的 分析股骨髁内生软骨瘤及股骨颈转移瘤误诊为非病理性骨折的原因,并探讨其早期鉴别诊断思路.方法 回顾性分析2025年6-9月收治的2例分别被误诊为"右股骨髁骨折"及"左股骨颈骨折"的股骨髁内生软骨瘤和股骨颈转移瘤患者的临床资料,梳理其临床特征、影像学表现及诊疗经过.结果 1例因"摔倒致右膝疼痛"就诊,急诊科结合X线及外院CT,诊断为"右侧股骨髁骨折",建议行骨折手术,予胫骨结节牵引,准备手术治疗.入院后CT提示病理性骨折可能,复查示D-二聚体升高及右下肢多发静脉血栓,穿刺活检未见明确恶性成分,结合影像学考虑"右股骨髁病理性骨折(软骨来源可能)";术后病理示成软骨性肿瘤(不典型软骨性肿瘤),伴骨折继发改变,修正诊断为"右股骨髁内生软骨瘤并病理性骨折";误诊时间4 d;明确诊断后给予神经阻滞+腰麻下行右股骨远端骨肿瘤刮除+股骨髁粉碎性病理性骨折切开复位+同侧髂骨+人工骨植骨内固定术,术后一期愈合,非负重膝关节屈伸功能练习,预防静脉血栓治疗.1例因"扭伤致左髋疼痛"就诊,根据X线检查结果诊断为"左股骨颈骨折",予皮牵引固定等治疗,追问病史后怀疑病理性骨折;入院前ECT已示左股骨颈骨代谢异常,CT示骨折断端圆滑伴溶骨破坏,肿瘤标志物升高,MRI示骨折伴骨髓水肿,经会诊修正诊断为"左股骨颈转移癌并病理性骨折";误诊时间2 d;确诊后给予左侧人工股骨头置换,术中将股骨颈处瘤体彻底切除,术后病理及免疫组织化学证实为骨转移性癌,术后预后良好.结论 对中老年骨折患者,应将骨折线形态不规则、断端圆钝溶骨、合并静脉血栓或肿瘤病史作为病理性骨折"影像+临床"红线;对可疑病例应即刻完善肿瘤标志物筛查及穿刺活检,避免按单纯骨折行内固定手术,减少误诊误治.
Objective To analyze the causes of misdiagnosis of femoral condyle enchondroma and femoral neck metastatic tumor as non-pathological fracture,and to investigate the early differential diagnostic approach.Methods The clinical data of 2 patients diagnosed with comminuted fracture of the right femoral condyle and left femoral neck fracture respectively from June to September 2025 were retrospectively analyzed.The clinical characteristics,imaging manifestations,and treatment processes were reviewed.Results One patient presented to Department of Emergency with right knee pain caused by a fall.The patient was diagnosed with right femoral condyle fracture based on X-ray and a CT scan from another hospital,and was recommended for fracture surgery.The patient was admitted to the Trauma Department,where tibial tubercle traction was applied to prepare for surgical treatment.After admission,CT scan suggested the possibility of pathological fracture,and the reexamination showed elevated D-dimer and multiple venous thrombosis in the right lower extremity.Puncture biopsy showed no definite malignant components.Combined with imaging findings,the lesion was diagnosed as a pathological fracture of the right femoral condyle(possibly of cartilaginous origin).Postoperative pathology showed cartilaginous tumor(atypical cartilaginous tumor)with secondary changes of fracture,and the diagnosis was revised to enchondroma of right femoral condyle with pathological fracture.The misdiagnosis lasted 4 d.After the diagnosis was confirmed,the patient was treated with curette of bone tumor in the right distal femur,open reduction of comminuted pathological fracture of the femoral condyle,ipsilateral iliac bone,and artificial bone grafting and internal fixation under nerve block and spinal anesthesia.The postoperative healing was primary,non-weight-bearing knee flexion and extension function exercises,and venous thrombosis prevention treatment were provided.One patient presented with left hip pain caused by sprain,was diagnosed with left femoral neck fracture according to X-ray examination,and was treated with skin traction and immobilization.After further inquiry into the medical history,a pathological fracture was suspected.ECT showed abnormal bone metabolism of the left femoral neck before admission,CT showed smooth fracture end with osteolytic destruction and increased tumor markers,and MRI showed fracture with bone marrow edema.After consultation,the patient was diagnosed with metastatic carcinoma of the left femoral neck with pathological fracture.The misdiagnosis lasted 2 d.After confirmation of the diagnosis,left artificial femoral head replacement was performed,and the tumor at the femoral neck was completely removed during the operation.Postoperative pathology and immunohistochemistry confirmed metastatic carcinoma of bone,and the postoperative prognosis was good.Conclusion For middle-aged and elderly fracture patients,irregular fracture lines,blunt osteolytic changes at the fracture ends,and a history of venous thrombosis or tumor should be considered imaging plus clinical red flags suggestive of a pathological fracture.For suspicious patients,tumor marker screening and needle biopsy should be immediately performed to avoid internal fixation surgery for simple fractures,to reduce misdiagnosis and mistreatment.
王振旺;王彦军;刘洪涛;柯嵩;李立东;李红都;王海军;苏立新
唐山市第二医院创伤科,河北唐山 063000唐山市第二医院创伤科,河北唐山 063000唐山市第二医院骨病科,河北唐山 063000唐山市第二医院创伤科,河北唐山 063000唐山市第二医院创伤科,河北唐山 063000唐山市第二医院创伤科,河北唐山 063000唐山市第二医院病案室,河北唐山 063000唐山市第二医院创伤科,河北唐山 063000
股骨髁内生软骨瘤股骨颈转移癌病理性骨折误诊股骨髁骨折股骨颈骨折病理学检查
femoral condyle enchondromafemoral neck metastatic tumorpathological fracturemisdiagnosisfemoral condyle fracturefemoral neck fracturepathological examination
《临床误诊误治》 2026 (10)
1-6,12,7
河北省2026年度医学科学研究课题(20261109)
评论