非侵入性脑刺激技术在卒中后失语症领域应用相关研究的文献计量学和可视化分析OA
Bibliometric and visual analysis of studies on non-invasive brain stimulation in post-stroke aphasia field
目的 探讨非侵入性脑刺激(NIBS)技术在卒中后失语症领域应用的研究现状、热点和趋势.方法 选取 Web of Science 核心合集作为数据来源,检索2007 年1 月1 日至2025 年12 月31 日发表的 NIBS 技术应用于卒中后失语症领域的相关文献,采用 VOSviewer 和 CiteSpace 等软件对文献发表数量、国家、机构、期刊、作者和关键词等信息进行文献计量和可视化分析.分别统计国家、机构、作者和关键词在各文献中共同出现的频次以构建共现网络.计算国家、机构、作者和关键词中心性以识别共现网络中连接不同知识集群的关键枢纽,并以中心性≥0.10 的节点作为关键节点.从 Web of Science 数据库获取作者的 H 指数.将期刊和关键词共现网络进行聚类分析,分别形成期刊共现聚类网络图和关键词聚类图.采用轮廓值作为关键词聚类质量的量化指标,平均轮廓值>0.5 表明聚类结构清晰合理.基于 Kleinberg 算法的突发检测功能对关键词突现进行检测以识别突现强度高的关键词.结果 (1)共纳入 Web of Science 数据库中2007 年1 月1 日至2025 年12 月31 日发表的 NIBS 技术在卒中后失语症领域应用的相关论著和综述 395 篇.各年度文献发表数量总体呈上升趋势,2009-2011 年、2016-2018 年、2020-2022 年、2023-2024 年文献发表数量增长明显,其中2024 年发表文献数量最多(35 篇).(2)共47 个国家发表了 NIBS 技术在卒中后失语症领域应用的相关文献,其中美国位居文献发表数量首位(134 篇),中心性 0.10;中国位居文献发表数量第2 位(69 篇),但中心性仅0.01;德国、意大利、英国文献发表数量分别位居第3、4、5 位;法国文献发表数量位居第8 位(19 篇),但中心性最高(0.24).文献发表数量排名前 5 位的国家中,美国、英国与相关研究网络内的大部分国家存在联系,是其中关键的中介节点;中国、意大利等近期发表数量较高的国家在相关研究网络中的影响力仍有待提升.美国共6 家机构位列文献发表数量前10 位,其中约翰斯·霍普金斯大学居首位(22 篇),哈佛大学及其医学联盟文献发表数量并列第2 位(均17 篇),且中心性均为0.15;圣卢西亚基金会科学诊疗研究所(14 篇)及哈佛医学院、巴黎公共医疗救助集团(巴黎公立医院集团)等5 家机构(均12 篇)文献发表数量亦位居前列.(3)发表相关文献的期刊中,Frontiers in Neurology 文献发表数量居首位(19 篇),Stroke 位居第 2 位(15 篇),但其被引次数最多(1 496 次).Aphasiology、Brain and Language 和 Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair 并列第3 位(均14 篇).发表相关文献的期刊主要分为神经科学与高级脑功能相关期刊(如Brain and Language、Neurocase 等)、前沿跨学科研究期刊(如 Frontiers in Neurology、Frontiers in Neuroscience 等)及临床神经病学期刊(如 Stroke、Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience 等)3 个聚类,各聚类间联系紧密.(4)文献发表数量排名前3 位的作者为美国约翰斯·霍普金斯大学 Hillis Argye E(12 篇;H 指数70)、美国南卡罗来纳大学哥伦比亚分校 Fridriksson Julius(11 篇;H 指数50)、英国曼彻斯特大学 Ralph Matthew A Lambon(10篇;H指数89).美国约翰斯·霍普金斯大学Hillis Argye E与意大利那不勒斯费德里克二世大学 Marangolo Paola 中心性较高(均为 0.02),余作者中心性均较低.文献发表数量排名前2 位的作者Hillis Argye E 和 Fridriksson Julius 联系紧密且具有团体化倾向,余作者间联系较少.(5)"tms(经颅磁刺激)""recovery(恢复)""stroke(卒中)""noninvasive brain stimulation(非侵入性脑刺激)""post-stroke aphasia(卒中后失语症)""language(语言)""non-fluent aphasia(非流畅性失语症)""speech(言语)""brain stimulation(脑刺激)"和"therapy(疗法)"是出现频次排名前10 位的关键词,其中"language(语言)"的中心性最高,为0.13.相关文献关键词主要分为12 个聚类("布洛卡区""重复经颅磁刺激""刺激参数""脑源性神经营养因子""MRI""语义认知""弓状束""词汇提取""认知综合征""言语语言治疗""前颞叶""激活")且聚类间高度交叉重叠,各聚类轮廓值均>0.5.相关文献中关键词突现强度排名前 3 位的关键词为"tms(经颅磁刺激)""rehabilitation(康复)"和"language therapy(语言治疗)";近 5 年突现强度排名前3 位的关键词分别为"language therapy(语言治疗)""theta burst stimulation(theta 爆发式磁刺激)"和"functional connectivity(功能连接).结论 2007-2025 年Web of Science 数据库中NIBS 技术在卒中后失语症领域应用的相关文献发表数量呈逐年上升趋势,美国、中国、德国、意大利、英国是该领域的主要研究力量,欧美高校与科研机构为核心产出来源.相关研究集中发表于神经科学及临床神经病学领域的权威与前沿跨学科期刊.高文献发表量的研究者间联系紧密且具有团体化倾向."语言治疗""theta 爆发式磁刺激""功能连接"为近期研究热点及未来研究趋势.
Objective To explore the research status,hotspots,and trends in the application of non-invasive brain stimulation(NIBS)technology in the field of post-stroke aphasia.Methods The Web of Science core collection was selected as the data source.The literature on the application of NIBS technology in post-stroke aphasia published from January 1,2007 to December 31,2025 were retrieved.Bibliometric and visual analyses of publication counts,countries,institutions,journals,authors,and keywords were performed using software such as VOSviewer and CiteSpace.The co-occurrence frequencies of countries,institutions,authors,and keywords within the same publication were counted to construct co-occurrence networks.The centrality of countries,institutions,authors,and keywords was calculated to identify key hubs connecting different knowledge clusters in the co-occurrence networks,with nodes having centrality≥0.10 considered key nodes.Authors' H-indices were obtained from the Web of Science database.Co-occurrence networks of journals and keywords were subjected to cluster analysis,forming journal co-occurrence cluster network maps and keyword cluster maps,respectively.The silhouette value was used as a quantitative indicator of keyword clustering quality,with an average silhouette value>0.5 indicating a clear and reasonable cluster structure.Keyword bursts were detected using the burst detection function based on Kleinberg's algorithm to identify keywords with high burst strength.Results(1)A total of 395 articles(including original research and reviews)on the application of NIBS technology in post-stroke aphasia published in the Web of Science database from January 1,2007 to December 31,2025 were included.The annual number of publications showed an overall upward trend,with significant growth observed during 2009-2011,2016-2018,2020-2022,and 2023-2024.The number of publications peaked in 2024(35articles).(2)A total of 47countries published relevant literature in the application of NIBS technology in post-stroke aphasia.The United States ranked first in publication count(134articles),with a centrality of 0.10.China ranked second(69 articles),but its centrality was only 0.01.Germany,Italy,and the United Kingdom ranked third,fourth,and fifth,respectively.France ranked eighth(19articles)but had the highest centrality(0.24).Among the top 5 courtiers with the highest publication counts,the United States and the United Kingdom maintained direct collaborative relationships with most other countries in the research network,serving as key intermediary nodes.In contrast,the publication impact of the countries with high recent publication counts within the international academic collaboration network,such as China and Italy,still remained modest and had potential for further improvement.Six of the top 10 institutions(in publication count)were from the United States,with Johns Hopkins University ranked first(22articles).Harvard University and its medical affiliates ranked second,each published 17articles,both with a centrality of 0.15.The IRCCS Santa Lucia(14articles),and including Harvard Medical School and Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris(AP-HP),the other five institutions(each with 12 articles)also ranked high in publication count.(3)The journal Frontiers in Neurology ranked first in publication count(19articles).Stroke ranked second(15 articles)but had the highest total citation count(1 496 citations).Aphasiology,Brain and Language,and Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair tied for third place(each with14 articles).Journals publishing relevant literature were mainly clustered into 3 groups:neuroscience and advanced brain function journals(e.g.,Brain and Language,Neurocase,etc.),frontier interdisciplinary research journals(e.g.,Frontiers in Neurology,Frontiers in Neuroscience,etc.),and clinical neurology journals(e.g.,Stroke,Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience,etc.).The clusters showed strong interconnections.(4)The top 3authors by publication count were Hillis Argye E from Johns Hopkins University,USA(12 articles,H-index 70);Fridriksson Julius from the University of South Carolina-Columbia,USA(11articles,H-index 50);and Ralph Matthew A Lambon from the University of Manchester,UK(10 articles,H-index 89).Hillis Argye E from Johns Hopkins University,USA,and Marangolo Paola from the University of Naples Federico Ⅱ,Italy,had relatively higher centrality(both 0.02),while other authors had lower centrality.The top 2authors,Hillis Argye E and Fridriksson Julius,had a close collaborative relationship with a tendency toward group formation,whereas the remaining authors showed limited collaborations.(5)The top 10 keywords by frequency were"transcranial magnetic stimulation(tms)""recovery""stroke""non-invasive brain stimulation""post-stroke aphasia""language""non-fluent aphasia""speech""brain stimulation"and"therapy".Among these,"language"had the highest centrality(0.13).Keywords were mainly divided into 12 clusters("Broca's area""repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation""stimulation parameters""brain-derived neurotrophic factor""MRI""semantic cognition""arcuate fasciculus""lexical access""cognitive syndromes""speech-language therapy""anterior temporal lobe""activation"),with high cross-overlap between clusters.The silhouette value for each cluster was>0.5.The top3keywords by burst strength in the relevant literature were"tms""rehabilitation"and"language therapy".The top 3 keywords by burst strength in the past five years were"language therapy""theta burst stimulation"and"functional connectivity".Conclusions From 2007 to 2025,the quantity of publications regarding the application of NIBS technology in post-stroke aphasia within the Web of Science database exhibited a year-on-year upward trend.The United States,China,Germany,Italy,and the United Kingdom are the principal research forces in this field,with universities and research institutions in Europe and America being the core output sources.Relevant research is concentrated in authoritative and cutting-edge journals in the fields of neuroscience and clinical neurology.Researchers with high publication volumes maintain close collaborations and exhibit a tendency toward teamwork.Among these,"language therapy""theta burst stimulation"and"functional connectivity"signify recent research hotspots and future trends.
陈嘉颖;黄婧慧;李颖;沈红建
200433 上海,海军军医大学第一附属医院康复医学科200433 上海,海军军医大学第一附属医院康复医学科200433 上海,海军军医大学第一附属医院康复医学科200433 上海,海军军医大学第一附属医院脑血管病中心
卒中失语症非侵入性脑刺激技术文献计量学
StrokeAphasiaNon-invasive brain stimulationBibliometrics
《中国脑血管病杂志》 2026 (4)
250-262,13
上海市科学技术委员会创新药械产品应用示范项目(25SF1907702)
评论