首页|期刊导航|太平洋学报|陆权困境能否循环?

陆权困境能否循环?OACHSSCD

Can the Land Power Dilemma Recur?

中文摘要英文摘要

近代以来,陆海大国竞斗结果往往呈现陆权屡败的困境循环,为何会出现此模式?本文通过分析19世纪以来英法竞斗、英俄竞斗和英德竞斗等经典案例,提出"安全条件—消耗性对抗—战略共识"的解释框架.研究发现,陆海大国因内在安全条件差异而陷入消耗性对抗,此高压情境催化作为第三方的关键陆权国形成明确的制衡共识,并与海权大国结盟,致使陆权大国陷入陆海双重遏制而最终失败.技术政治时代该理论框架发生深刻调适:技术变革作为重组性变量与传统地理要素深度耦合,驱动竞争从地理空间主导转向技术—地理主导,从高烈度间歇性竞斗转向常态化极致消耗,并使外部反应模式面临高度复杂化与不确定性.技术政治时代大国竞争的安全条件和战略共识演变,使近代陆权屡败的经典因果链被打破.因此,虽然技术政治时代的大国竞争并未终结且仍有近代特征,但是,陆权困境得以超越的可能性已经显现,并形成围绕技术和体系的长期博弈.

Since modern times,the rivalry between land powers and sea powers has often resulted in the recurring dilemma of land powers suffering repeated defeats.Why does this pattern emerge?By analyzing classic cases such as the Anglo-French,Anglo-Russian,and Anglo-German rivalries since the 19th century,this paper proposes an explanatory framework of"security conditions,enduring rivalry,strategic consensus."Research reveals that land powers and sea powers,driven by inherent differences in their security conditions,become entangled in enduring rivalry.This high-pressure environment catalyzes crucial land powers—as third parties—to form explicit counterbalancing consensus and forge alliances with sea powers,ultimately trapping the land power in dual containment from both land and sea,leading to its demise.In the era of technopolitics,this theoretical framework undergoes profound adaptation:technological transformation,as a reconfiguring variable,deeply couples with traditional geographic factors.This drives competition to shift from geographic-space dominance to techno-geographic dominance,and from high-intensity intermittent rivalry to normalized extreme attrition.It also renders external response patterns highly complex and uncertain.By analyzing the evolution of security conditions and strategic consensus in great power competition in the technopolitical era,this paper argues that the classic causal chain that led to the repeated defeats of land powers in modern times has been broken.Therefore,although great power competition in the technopolitical era persists with modern characteristics,the possibility of transcending the land power dilemma has emerged,giving rise to long-term strategic games centered on technology and systems.

李清扬;杜哲元

上海外国语大学,上海 201620中国政法大学,北京 100088

社会科学

陆海大国竞斗安全条件战略共识消耗性对抗技术政治时代

land-sea power rivalrysecurity conditionsstrategic consensusenduring rivalrythe era of technopolitics

《太平洋学报》 2026 (4)

78-98,21

本文系教育部哲学社会科学研究重大专项"国际政治与中国政治学自主知识体系建构研究"(2025JZDZ021)的阶段性研究成果,系中国政法大学青年教师学术创新团队"大变局下中国对外安全战略研究"(25CXTD03)资助成果.

10.14015/j.cnki.1004-8049.2026.04.007

评论