犯罪学研究方法的路径重构OACHSSCD

Reimagining Criminological Research Methods:Insights from Feyerabend's Against Method

中文摘要英文摘要

犯罪学作为一门跨学科领域的科学,其研究方法深受传统科学范式的影响,呈现出单一化、标准化和实证化的倾向.然而,这种方法论体系忽视犯罪现象的复杂多样,理论与实践间僵化脱节,缺乏对犯罪现象的深入解释.费耶阿本德在《反对方法》一书中批判传统方法论,提出了"怎么都行"的方法论,批判了科学相对于非科学(如经验传统等)的优越性,倡导通过引入不相容理论的"反归纳"法构筑多元主义方法论.受这一理论启发,犯罪学可广泛吸收多元方法,发挥以实践为基础的经验的作用,构筑动态的方法论体系,以此突破研究方法的局限性,提倡多元主义方法论,并尝试构建一种基 于 自 由、多样和开放的犯罪学研究方法体系,推动犯罪学理论与实践的协同创新.

Criminology is an interdisciplinary science that has long been influenced by traditional scientific paradigms in its research methods.This has led to tendencies towards singularity,standardization and positivism.However,this system of methodology overlooks the complexity and diversity of criminal phenomena,resulting in a rigid disconnect between theory and practice,as well as a failure to provide an in-depth explanation of criminal phenomena.In Against Method,Feyerabend critiques traditional methodology,proposing an"anything goes"approach to methodology.He challenges the presumed superiority of scientific methods over non-scientific approaches,such as empirical traditions,and advocates constructing a pluralistic methodology through the"counter-induction"of introducing incompatible theories.Inspired by this theory,criminology can broadly absorb diverse methods,leverage the role of practice-based empirical traditions,and construct a dynamic methodological system.This approach aims to transcend the limitations of research methods,advocate for methodological pluralism,and attempt to establish a criminological research method system grounded in freedom,diversity,and openness,thereby promoting synergistic innovation between criminological theory and practice.

朱恺音;李羽昕

华东政法大学 刑事法学院,上海 200042华东政法大学 刑事法学院,上海 200042

社会科学

犯罪学研究方法费耶阿本德《反对方法》

criminologyresearch methodsFeyerabendAgainst Method

《徐州工程学院学报(社会科学版)》 2026 (1)

17-23,7

2025年度上海市教卫党委系统党建理论研究会课题"基于情景犯罪学视角的政治监督具体化、精准化、常态化机制研究"(2025ZX032)

评论