面向批判性思维的教学反思智能体:模型构建及实证研究OA
An Intelligent Agent for Teaching Reflection on Critical Thinking:Model Construction and Empirical Study
向学生提供恰当的反思支持是促进批判性思维的关键机制,但传统反思方式在个性化支持和生成式人工智能"伪反思"的挑战下仍存在局限性,教学反思智能体为重构反思机制带来了新契机,而其对批判性思维的影响尚待深入探究.为此,文章基于批判性思维与 GIBBS 反思循环理论,构建面向批判性思维的教学反思智能体模型,并采用准实验设计方法,以华中地区 S 大学"互联网思维与数字化自主学习"课程的两个班级学生为研究对象开展实证研究,以验证教学反思智能体的有效性.结果显示,教学反思智能体整体上显著提升了学生的批判性思维水平;高、低绩效组的批判性思维提升效果存在显著差异,高绩效组批判性思维的提升效果更优,低绩效组在反思兴趣与能力提升方面受益较多.文章旨在为智能反思工具的适切性教学设计与批判性思维优化策略提供理论和实践参考.
Providing students with appropriate reflective support is a key mechanism for fostering critical thinking,but traditional reflection methods remain limited in terms of personalized support and face challenge from"pseudo-reflection"caused by generative artificial intelligence.Teaching reflection agents have brought new opportunities for reconstructing reflection mechanisms,yet their impact on critical thinking remain to be thoroughly explored.Accordingly,based on critical thinking and GIBBS reflective theory,this paper constructed a teaching reflection agent model oriented toward critical thinking.Using a quasi-experimental design,the study conducted an empirical study with two classes from University S in Central China taking the"Internet Thinking and Digital Autonomous Learning"course to verify the effectiveness of the teaching reflection agent.The results showed that the teaching reflection agent significantly improved students'overall critical thinking levels.There were notable differences in the enhancement effects between high-and low-performing groups:the high-performing group exhibited greater improvement in critical thinking,while the low-performing group benefited more in terms of reflective interest and competency development.This study aimed to provide theoretical and practical references for the targeted instructional design of intelligent reflection tools and optimization strategies for critical thinking.
郑玉敏;陈露露;上超望;蒙江;赵玉林
华中师范大学 人工智能教育学部,湖北 武汉 430079华中师范大学 人工智能教育学部,湖北 武汉 430079华中师范大学 人工智能教育学部,湖北 武汉 430079华中师范大学 人工智能教育学部,湖北 武汉 430079华中师范大学 人工智能教育学部,湖北 武汉 430079
社会科学
教学反思智能体批判性思维生成式人工智能反思策略
instructional reflection agentcritical thinkinggenerative artificial intelligencereflection strategies
《现代教育技术》 2026 (5)
59-68,10
本文为教育部人文社科规划基金项目"生成式AI嵌入学习评价场域中算法偏见的发生机理及干预策略研究"(项目编号:NO.25YJAZH142)的阶段性研究成果.
评论