职业体育联盟亏损帽政策的投资约束与竞争促进效果研究OACHSSCD
Investment Restraint and Competition Promotion Effects of the Loss Cap Policy in Professional Sports Leagues
亏损帽政策作为控制俱乐部过度投资、促进联盟竞争性平衡的规制性工具,近年来逐渐应用于中国职业体育发展.本文通过博弈论与静态优化方法系统分析亏损帽政策的适用条件及其促进效果:当惩罚措施十分严格时,亏损帽政策能够限制俱乐部投资并促进联盟竞争性平衡,但会导致投资骤降、比赛质量下滑,损害联赛吸引力;当惩罚措施较为宽松时,亏损帽政策也能限制俱乐部投资,但对联盟竞争性平衡的影响取决于惩罚成本在不同俱乐部间是否对称(当各俱乐部违规成本相同即对称时,政策可持续促进平衡;若大俱乐部因财力雄厚而实际承担更轻惩罚即不对称时,政策效果可能先改善后恶化).为此提出政策建议:亏损帽政策的惩罚机制应避免"一刀切"禁赛,而是采用罚款、扣分等柔性组合措施,并依据俱乐部营收设定差异化弹性上限.同时,必须确保惩罚规则执行一致透明,并建立动态评估机制,以实现财务健康、竞争平衡与比赛吸引力的长期协调.
As a regulatory tool to control excessive club investment and to promote competitive balance in leagues,the loss cap policy has gradually been applied to the development of professional sports in China in recent years.This study systematically analyzes the applicable conditions and promotion effects of the loss cap policy by using game theory and static optimization methods.It finds that when punitive measures are very strict,the loss cap policy can limit club investment and promote competitive balance in leagues,but may also lead to a sharp decline in investment,game quality and league appeal;when punitive measures are relatively lenient,the loss cap policy can still limit club investment,but its impact on competitive balance depends on whether the cost of punishment is symmetric across clubs(i.e.,if costs are the same for all clubs,the policy can sustainably promote balance;if large clubs face lighter penalties due to greater financial strength,the policy effects may first improve and then deteriorate).Therefore,the study proposes the following policy recommendations:the penalty mechanism of the loss cap policy should avoid the"one-size-fits-all"ban,instead adopting flexible combinations of measures such as fines and point deductions,and set differentiated flexible caps based on club revenue.Furthermore,it is essential to ensure consistent and transparent rule enforcement and establish a dynamic evaluation mechanism to achieve long-term coordination of financial health,competitive balance,and game attractiveness.
汪升;周腾军;王志远
安徽大学 体育军事教学部,安徽 合肥 230601西南财经大学 体育与经济管理研究中心,四川 成都 611130同济大学 国际足球学院,上海 200092
社会科学
职业体育联盟竞赛机制亏损帽博弈论竞争性平衡
professional sports leaguecontest mechanismloss capgame theorycompetitive balance
《沈阳体育学院学报》 2026 (2)
85-91,7
安徽省哲学社会科学规划一般项目(AHSKY2025D15)上海市哲学社会科学规划课题(2023ETY001).
评论