历史建筑定损评估技术研究OACSSCI
Damage Evaluation Techniques for Historic Buildings:Exemplified by a Republican-era Building in Jing'an District,Shanghai
历史建筑定损评估是一项融合文化遗产价值判读与经济价值计量的专业评估活动.文章基于成本法理论框架,构建了以复建/修缮成本为价值基础、结合德尔菲法进行文化遗产价值损失调整的评估技术模型;系统阐释了"完全损坏"与"部分损坏"的界定标准,辨析了"重建成本"与"重置成本"在历史建筑定损评估中的适用边界;并通过上海市静安区某民国建筑的实证研究验证了该技术模型的可行性与适用性.研究表明,该模型通过"成本基价+文化遗产价值系数调整"的双轨路径,为司法裁量、行政处罚及损害赔偿提供了兼具专业性与可操作性的量化依据,为完善我国历史建筑保护管理体系中的损害赔偿机制提供了方法论支撑.
The damage evaluation of historic buildings is a specialised activity that integrates value assessment with the economic evaluation of cultural heritage.Based on the theoretical frame-work of the cost approach,this article constructs a technical evaluation model that uses reconstruction and repair costs as the value foundation,and com-bines the Delphi method to adjust cultural heritage value loss.It systematically elaborates the defining criteria for'total loss'and'partial loss',clarifies the applicable boundaries of'reproduction cost'versus'replacement cost'in the damage evaluation of historic buildings,and validates the feasibility and applicability of this technical model through an empirical study of a Republican-era(1912-1949)building in Jing'an District,Shanghai.The analysis demonstrates that this proposed model,through a dual-track path of'base cost+cultural heritage value coefficient adjustment',provides a quantitative basis combining professional ex-pertise with operability for judicial discretion,administrative penalties,and damage compensa-tion.This article offers methodological support for improving the damage compensation mechanism within the management system of historic building conservation in China.
叶剑;李新建;徐进亮
苏州名城保护集团(苏州215005)东南大学建筑学院(南京210096)东南大学建筑学院(南京210096)||城市与建筑遗产保护教育部重点实验室(东南大学)
建筑与水利
历史建筑定损评估德尔菲法成本法
historic buildingsdamage evaluationDelphi methodcost approach
《建筑遗产》 2025 (3)
87-93,7
国家自然科学基金(52178010)江苏省社会科学重点基金(25WTA-016) National Natural Science Foundation of China(52178010)Jiangsu Provincial Key Social Science Fund(25WTA-016)
评论