基于可解释机器学习的中青年男性骨量减少预测模型的建立OA
Development of a prediction model for osteopenia in young and middle-aged males based on explainable machine learning
目的 基于体检数据集探究中青年男性骨量减少相关的风险因素,构建预测模型并评估其效能.方法 选取2022年5月-2024年5月于联勤保障部队第961医院体检的989名健康中青年男性体检人员为研究对象进行数据回顾性研究,按7:3的比例将数据集随机分为训练集(n=692)与验证集(n=297),以研究对象发生骨量减少为主要研究终点.采用LASSO回归筛选独立预后因素,采用6种机器学习模型,即极限梯度提升、支持向量机、多因素逻辑回归、K-最近邻算法、轻量级梯度提升机及随机森林预测研究对象的骨量减少情况.采用受试者操作特征(ROC)曲线下面积(AUC)、敏感度、特异度及Brier评分等指标筛选最优模型.采用Youden指数最大化原则确定高风险概率阈值.通过校准曲线和临床决策曲线评价最佳模型的校准度及临床表现.最终采用SHAP方法解释最优模型的预测结果.结果 研究确定了中青年男性患者骨量减少的8种独立影响因素,分别为吸烟情况、高密度脂蛋白胆固醇、甘油三酯、红细胞计数、规律运动、血清白蛋白、血红蛋白、尿酸.采用不同方法构建的6种机器学习模型,其中以RF模型表现出的预测性能最佳,其验证集的AUC(0.706,95%CI 0.644~0.769)、特异度(0.884)、阳性预测值(0.704)、阴性预测值(0.708)、准确率(0.704)均为各模型最高,Brier评分最优,为0.0301(0.0283~0.0322)分.Youden指数最大值为0.384,对应敏感度0.579、特异度0.805.验证集校准曲线在概率0.20~0.65内偏离最小.验证集的临床决策曲线在风险阈值0.12~0.65内净获益为正,支持其用于临床决策.结论 吸烟情况、高密度脂蛋白胆固醇、甘油三酯、红细胞计数、规律运动、血清白蛋白、血红蛋白、尿酸是中青年男性发生骨量减少的独立影响因素.基于这些因素构建的预测模型具备较好的预测效能,可为临床诊疗提供基于循证医学的辅助决策支持.
Objective To explore the risk factors associated with osteopenia in young and middle-aged males based on the health examination dataset,and to develop a predictive model and evaluate its performance.Methods A total of 989 healthy young and middle-aged male participants who underwent health examination at the 961st Hospital of the Joint Logistics Support Force between May 2022 and May 2024 were included in the retrospective study.The dataset was randomly divided into a training set(n=692)and a validation set(n=297)at a 7:3 ratio.The occurrence of osteopenia in participants was defined as the primary study endpoint.Independent risk factors were selected via LASSO regression.Six machine learning models,including extreme gradient boosting,support vector machine,multivariate logistic regression,K-nearest neighbors,light gradient boosting machine,and random forest,were employed to predict osteopenia in the study subjects.The optimal model was identified based on metrics including the area under the receiver operating characteristic curves(AUC),sensitivity,specificity,and the Brier score.The high-risk probability threshold was determined using the principle of maximizing the Youden index.Calibration and clinical utility of the best-performing model were assessed using calibration curves and decision curve analysis.Finally,the SHAP method was applied to interpret the predictions of the optimal model.Results Eight independent factors for osteopenia in young and middle-aged male participants were identified:smoking status,high-density lipoprotein cholesterol,triglyceride level,red blood cell count,regular exercise,serum albumin level,hemoglobin level,and uric acid level.Six machine learning models were constructed using different algorithms.Among them,the RF model demonstrated the best predictive performance,achieving the highest validation set AUC of 0.706(95%CI 0.644-0.769),specificity(0.884),positive predictive value(0.704),negative predictive value(0.708),and accuracy(0.704).It also yielded the optimal Brier score of 0.0301(0.0283-0.0322).The maximum Youden index was 0.384,corresponding to a sensitivity of 0.579 and a specificity of 0.805.The calibration curve for the validation set showed minimal deviation within the probability range of 0.20-0.65.The decision curve for the validation set indicated a positive net benefit within the risk threshold range of 0.12-0.65,supporting its potential utility in decision-making.Conclusion Smoking status,high-density lipoprotein cholesterol,triglyceride level,red blood cell count,regular exercise,serum albumin level,hemoglobin level,and uric acid level are independent influencing factors for osteopenia in young and middle-aged males.The prediction model constructed based on these factors demonstrates satisfactory predictive performance and can provide evidence-based decision support for clinical diagnosis and treatment.
李开源;宋泽辉;于淼;杨振伟;侯丽雪
联勤保障部队第961医院急诊与重症医学科,黑龙江 齐齐哈尔 161000联勤保障部队第961医院急诊与重症医学科,黑龙江 齐齐哈尔 161000联勤保障部队第961医院急诊与重症医学科,黑龙江 齐齐哈尔 161000联勤保障部队第961医院急诊与重症医学科,黑龙江 齐齐哈尔 161000联勤保障部队第961医院急诊与重症医学科,黑龙江 齐齐哈尔 161000
医药卫生
骨量减少机器学习SHAP方法辅助决策支持
osteopeniamachine learningSHAP methoddecision support
《解放军医学杂志》 2026 (3)
354-362,9
This work was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China(2023YFF1203805),and the Qiqihar City Science and Technology Plan Innovation Incentive Project(CSFGG-2025029) 国家重点研发计划(2023YFF1203805)齐齐哈尔市科技计划创新激励项目(CSFGG-2025029)
评论