百年变局下的全球移民治理:议题、框架与展望OACHSSCD
Global Migration Governance in an Era of Great Changes:Issues,Frameworks,and Prospects
当今世界正经历百年未有之大变局,全球治理体系处于深刻变革与重构的关键时期.自2021年以来,中国先后提出全球发展倡议、全球安全倡议、全球文明倡议和全球治理倡议,成为贡献于全球治理的"中国方案".而移民治理作为全球治理的关键一环,成为检验全球治理效能的重要场域.中国在全球移民网络中的地位已从单纯的输出国向"输出国—中间国—输入国"三重属性转变,特别是随着"一带一路"倡议、金砖国家、上海合作组织等国际合作机制和经贸合作的深化,更深的全球移民治理卷入已不可回避. 基于四大全球倡议,构建"价值理念—主体结构—治理机制—实践路径"四维分析框架,以期突破传统研究的西方中心主义范式,将四大全球倡议的系统理念转化为具体分析工具,为解析全球移民治理体系的结构特征与演进逻辑提供新的理论视角.面对全球移民趋向的重大转变,全球移民治理围绕国家主权与个人权利保护的平衡、移民社会融合与再融合、迁移管理与发展引导、危机应对与安全治理、技术赋能与数字治理五大核心议题,在"权利—发展—安全"三维价值导向上呈现出动态耦合特征.基于对"全球—区域—国家—次国家"多层级全球移民治理体系的系统分析,揭示当前全球移民治理体系存在的四大核心问题和挑战,包括价值导向上的泛安全化与权利缺失、主体结构的代表性不足与责任分担失衡、治理机制上的碎片化与软法化倾向、实践路径上的短期主义与执行力问题.提出未来全球移民治理体系创新完善的基本思路,包括确立"以人为本、包容发展与综合安全"的价值理念、构建"多元主体—权责平衡—包容性参与"的主体结构、强化"多边主义—国际法治—数字治理"的治理机制、推进以行动导向为核心的合作共赢进程. 在此过程中,中国可以扮演"倡议者—协调者—行动者"的多重角色,通过理念贡献、制度创新和务实合作,为推动构建更加公正合理的全球移民治理体系提供中国方案.此外,在构建全球治理自主知识体系视域下提出未来全球移民治理研究的重要方向,包括迁移动力与治理效能的深化研究、治理体系与知识生产的范式创新、技术赋能全球移民治理的前沿探索,以及中国角色的系统性研究与战略应对,为推动全球移民治理体系向着更加包容、公正、有效的方向发展提供学术支撑.
The world is undergoing"profound changes unseen in a century",and the global governance system is at a critical juncture of deep transformation and restructuring.Since 2021,China has successively proposed the Global Development Initiative(GDI),the Global Security Initiative(GSI),the Global Civilization Initiative(GCI),and the Global Governance Initiative(GGI),collectively forming the"China Solution"contributing to global governance.As a crucial component of global governance,migration governance has become a key arena for testing the efficacy of the global governance system. China's role in the global migration network has shifted from solely a sending country to a triple attribute of sending,transit,and receiving country.China's deeper involvement in migration governance has become irreversible.Based on the Four Global Initiatives(GDI,GSI,GCI,GGI),this study constructs a comprehensive four-dimensional analytical framework.This framework aims to break through the traditional Western-centric paradigm in existing research,systematically translating the philosophical concepts of the Four Global Initiatives into specific analytical tools,thereby offering a new theoretical perspective for analyzing the structural features and evolutionary logic of the global migration governance system. In response to profound shifts in global migration patterns,global migration governance revolves around five core issues:the balance between national sovereignty and individual rights,the social integration and reintegration of migrants,the alignment of migration management and sustainable development,the nexus of crisis response and security governance,and the integration of technological empowerment and digital governance.These issues exhibit dynamic coupling across the three dimensions of rights,development,and security.Based on a systematic analysis of the multi-level governance architecture—global,regional,national,and subnational dimensions—this study identifies four fundamental challenges existing in the current global migration governance system:pan-securitization and rights deficit in value orientation;insufficient representation and imbalanced responsibility sharing within the institutional framework;fragmentation and soft-law tendency of governance mechanism;and the prevalence of short-termism and implementation gaps in practical pathway. Furthermore,this study proposes the fundamental ideas for the refinement of global migration governance.These include internalizing people-centered values and a holistic view of security;building a multi-stakeholder framework characterized by balanced rights and responsibilities,and inclusive participation;reinforcing governance mechanism through multilateralism,international rule of law and digital governance and advancing an action-oriented process of win-win cooperation.In this landscape,China is poised to fulfill the multiple roles of initiator,coordinator,and actor and offers a distinct contribution to foster a more just and reasonable global migration governance system. Finally,this study proposes critical directions for future research on global migration governance within the perspective of constructing an independent knowledge system for global governance.These include the refinement and validation of the global migration governance theoretical framework,in-depth research on migration dynamics and governance efficacy,paradigmatic innovation in governance systems and knowledge production,cutting-edge exploration of technological empowerment and ethical governance.Systematic research on China's role and strategic responses is also emphasized to provide academic support for a more inclusive,just and effective global migration governance system.
李树茁;白萌;袁玥
西安交通大学 公共政策与管理学院,陕西 西安 710049西安交通大学 公共政策与管理学院,陕西 西安 710049西南财经大学 社会发展研究院,四川 成都 611130
社会科学
全球治理移民治理四大全球倡议治理议题权利—发展—安全治理价值导向治理框架中国方案
global governancemigration governancefour global initiativesgovernance agendasrights-development-securityvalue orientation of governancegovernance frameworkthe China solution
《西安交通大学学报(社会科学版)》 2026 (1)
9-28,20
教育部哲学社会科学重大专项项目(2025JZDZ049)国家社会科学基金一般项目(22BRK024)国家社会科学基金青年项目(24CRK036)国家自然科学基金面上项目(72074179).
评论