推拿联合运动疗法在退行性肩袖损伤患者中的疗效观察OA
Efficacy of Tuina Combined with Exercise Therapy for Patients with Degenerative Rotator Cuff Tears:A Randomized Controlled Trial
目的:评估在退行性肩袖损伤患者中,中医推拿联合标准化运动疗法相比于假推拿联合运动疗法或单独运动疗法,能否在改善肩关节功能与生活质量方面带来显著的附加益处.方法:本研究为一项三臂、平行分组、随机、评估者盲化的对照临床试验,共招募63名经影像学确诊的退行性肩袖损伤患者,随机分配至A组(推拿+运动疗法)、B组(假推拿+运动疗法)或C组(仅运动疗法),所有干预均持续12周.主要结局指标为西安大略肩袖指数(WORC)评分,次要结局指标包括视觉模拟评分(VAS)和肩关节活动度.结果:治疗12周后,三组在WORC评分上存在显著统计学差异(P<0.05).两两比较显示,A组的改善显著优于B组(P<0.05)和C组(P<0.05),而B组与C组间差异无统计学意义.在次要指标中,A组在肩关节屈曲(P<0.05)和外展(P<0.05)活动度的改善上显著优于其他两组.各组在疼痛缓解(VAS)上无显著差异(P>0.05).研究期间未发生严重不良事件.结论:在标准化运动疗法的基础上联合中医推拿,能为退行性肩袖损伤患者带来超越安慰剂效应的、显著的附加临床益处,尤其是在改善肩关节功能、生活质量及活动度等方面.本研究结果支持将中医推拿作为一种安全有效的辅助疗法纳入该疾病的综合保守治疗方案中.
Objective:To evaluate whether Tuina combined with standardized exercise therapy provides significant additional benefits in improving shoulder function and quality of life compared to sham Tuina plus exercise therapy or exercise therapy alone in patients with degenerative rotator cuff tears.Methods:This was a three-arm,parallel-group,randomized,assessor-blinded controlled clinical trial.A total of 63 patients with radiologically confirmed degenerative rotator cuff tears were recruited and randomly assigned to Group A(Tuina+exercise therapy),Group B(sham Tuina+exercise therapy),and Group C(exercise therapy alone).All interventions lasted for 12 weeks.The primary outcome measure was the Western Ontario Rotator Cuff(WORC)index score.Secondary outcomes included the Visual Analogue Scale(VAS)for pain assessment and shoulder range of motion(ROM).Results:After 12 weeks of treatment,there was a statistically significant difference in the WORC score among the three groups(P<0.05).Post-hoc comparisons indicated that the improvement in Group A was significantly superior to that in Group B(P<0.05)and Group C(P<0.05),while no significant difference was observed between Group B and Group C.Regarding secondary outcomes,Group A showed significantly greater improvements in shoulder flexion(P<0.05)and abduction(P<0.05)ROM compared with the other two groups.There were no significant differences in VAS pain relief among the three groups(P>0.05).No serious adverse events occurred during the study period.Conclusion:Adding Chinese Tuina to standardized exercise therapy offers significant clinical benefits beyond the placebo effect for patients with degenerative rotator cuff tears,especially in improving shoulder function,quality of life,and ROM.The findings of this study support the inclusion of Chinese Tuina as a safe and effective adjunctive therapy in the comprehensive conservative treatment regimen for this condition.
陈乙彬;李义凯
揭阳市中医院,广东 揭阳 522000南方医科大学,广东 广州 510515||南方医科大学南方医院,广东 广州 510515
医药卫生
退行性肩袖撕裂推拿疗法运动疗法安慰剂效应肩关节功能肩关节活动度视觉模拟量表西安大略肩袖指数辅助治疗保守治疗
degenerative rotator cuff tearTuina therapyexercise therapyplacebo effectshoulder functionshoulder range of motionVisual Analogue ScaleWestern Ontario Rotator Cuff indexadjunctive therapyconservative treatment
《中医康复》 2026 (2)
90-95,6
评论