中成药治疗慢性胆囊炎的安全性、有效性和经济性评价OA
Evaluation of safety,efficacy and economy of proprietary Chinese medicines in the treatment of chronic cholecystitis
目的:对治疗慢性胆囊炎的中成药开展临床综合评价,以期为治疗胆囊炎的临床药物选择及卫生部门决策提供参考.方法:通过网状Meta分析评价治疗慢性胆囊炎中成药的安全性、有效性;以有效性评价结果为依据,采用成本-效果分析评价经济性,当有效性结果无显著差异时使用最小成本分析.结果:从有效性看,各中成药之间各结局指标并无差异,但基本都较常规西药治疗更优;从安全性看,各中成药均比常规西药好,但各药品之间无统计学差异;从经济性看,成本最低的是金胆片(12.74元),最高的鸡骨草胶囊(100.80元),按照顺序依次金胆片<消炎利胆片<胆舒胶囊<胆宁片<胆康胶囊<鸡骨草胶囊.结论:本研究各中成药在临床慢性胆囊炎的治疗中应用广泛,且具有较好的疗效和安全性,具有一定的临床应用价值,可根据患者的经济情况进行临床决策.
Objective:To conduct a comprehensive clinical evaluation of Chinese patent medicines for chronic cholecystitis,with the aim of providing evidence for clinical drug selection and informing decision-making by health authorities.Methods:A net-work meta-analysis was performed to compare the safety and efficacy of various Chinese patent medicines in treating chronic chole-cystitis.Based on the efficacy outcomes,a cost-effectiveness analysis was conducted to evaluate their economic value.A cost-minimi-zation analysis was employed when no significant difference in efficacy was found.Results:In terms of efficacy,while no significant differences were detected among the various Chinese patent medicines themselves across multiple outcome measures,they collec-tively demonstrated superior effectiveness when compared with conventional Western medicine.Regarding safety,all Chinese patent medicines were associated with fewer adverse events than conventional Western medicine,with no statistically significant differences observed among them.The economic evaluation revealed substantial cost variation,with Jindan Tablets being the least expensive(CNY 12.74)and Jigucao Capsules the most costly(CNY 100.80).The products ranked in ascending order of cost were:Jindan Tablets<Xiaoyan Lidan Tablets<Danshu Capsules<Danning Tablets<Dankang Capsules<Jigucao Capsules.Conclusion:The findings of this study collectively demonstrate that the evaluated Chinese patent medicines are widely applicable,effective,and safe in the clinical management of chronic cholecystitis,indicating their considerable therapeutic value.These agents present viable treatment options,the selection of which can be guided by patient economic circumstances.
徐瑶;李邦艳;赵美娟;王世宇
成都中医药大学 药学院,四川 成都 611137成都中医药大学 药学院,四川 成都 611137成都中医药大学 药学院,四川 成都 611137成都中医药大学 药学院,四川 成都 611137
医药卫生
中成药慢性胆囊炎临床综合评价
Proprietary Chinese medicinechronic cholecystitisclinical comprehensive evaluation
《中药与临床》 2026 (1)
41-47,7
评论