民航机场飞行区安全事件致因分析的DEMATEL-ISM-BN模型OACSCD
A DEMATEL-ISM-BN Model for Causation Analysis of Safety Incidents in Civil Aviation Airport Flight Area
针对机场飞行区安全风险演化路径不清、难以动态预测的问题,研究了集成决策实验室分析、解释结构模型与贝叶斯网络的耦合致因分析模型.基于航空器事件调查报告、文献与专家知识等,构建包含人、机、环、管4个维度的飞行区安全事件致因因素体系.采用改进的决策实验室分析/解释结构模型方法解析致因因素因果关系并构建多级递阶结构:在决策实验室分析阶段融合客观事故致因链与专家判断以提升关系判定的准确性;在解释结构模型层级划分后保留关键跨层级关系,增强网络结构对系统复杂性的刻画能力.将优化后的拓扑映射为贝叶斯网络,通过优化先验概率与条件概率的确定方法,贝叶斯参数估计实现飞行区安全事件概率的正向预测与致因链的逆向诊断.华北地区某机场的实证结果表明:飞行区安全事件先验发生概率为4.26%,证据输入下概率区间为4.38%~14.00%;逆向诊断识别出关键致因链为:部门协调沟通机制不完善→沟通协调配合失误→应急处置失当→飞行区安全事件.与现有研究对比显示,本模型在因素关系识别方面优于依赖问卷的结构方程模型方法,路径逻辑更清晰;在风险推演能力上实现从静态相关分析到动态概率推断的跨越,支持实时预警与根因追溯.案例分析结果与真实事故调查高度吻合,验证模型在飞行区安全管理中具有较高实用价值与可靠性.
This study proposes a coupled causal analysis model integrating decision making trial and evaluation lab-oratory,interpretative structural modeling,and Bayesian network to address challenges in clarifying risk evolution paths and enabling dynamic prediction for airport flight area safety.A causal factor system for safety incidents is first constructed,covering human,equipment,environment,and management dimensions,based on aircraft incident reports,literature,and expert knowledge.The improved decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory method inte-grates objective accident causation chains with expert judgments to enhance relationship identification accuracy.The interpretative structural modeling then establishes a multi-level hierarchical structure,explicitly preserving criti-cal cross-level relationships to better characterize system complexity.This optimized topology is mapped into a Bayesian network.Through improved methods for determining prior and conditional probabilities,the Bayesian pa-rameter estimation enables the forward prediction of incident probabilities and the backward diagnosis of critical causation chains.A case study of an airport in North China demonstrates the model's effectiveness.The prior proba-bility of a flight area safety incident is 4.26%.Under different evidence inputs,the probability dynamically ranges between 4.38%and 14.00%.Backward diagnosis identifies the key causation chain as:"imperfect departmental co-ordination mechanism→communication and coordination failure→inadequate emergency response→flight area safety incident".Comparisons with existing studies,such as questionnaire-based structural equation modeling,show the proposed model provides clearer path logic and advances from static correlation analysis to dynamic probabilis-tic inference.The case analysis results align closely with actual accident findings,validating the model's practical utility and reliability in proactive safety management for airport flight areas.
韩亚雄;初良勇;冯广洪;刘泉
集美大学航海学院 福建 厦门 361021||鄂尔多斯应用技术学院大飞机学院 内蒙古 鄂尔多斯 017000集美大学航海学院 福建 厦门 361021民航贵州空管分局管制运行部 贵阳 550002鄂尔多斯应用技术学院大飞机学院 内蒙古 鄂尔多斯 017000
航空航天
交通安全机场飞行区致因分析决策实验室分析解释结构模型贝叶斯网络
traffic safetyairport flight areacausal analysisdecision making trial and evaluation laboratoryinter-pretative structural modelingBayesian network
《交通信息与安全》 2025 (5)
57-69,13
国家社会科学基金重大项目(23&ZD138)、鄂尔多斯高校科研创新"三清零四提升"青年基金项目(KYQN25Z004)、鄂尔多斯应用技术学院科研项目(KYYB2022007)资助
评论