经皮冠状动脉介入治疗术后患者心脏康复依从性潜在类别转变及其影响因素研究OA
Study on the Latent Class Transition and Its Influencing Factors of Cardiac Rehabilitation Adherence in Post-PCI Patients
目的 分析经皮冠状动脉介入治疗(PCI)术后患者心脏康复依从性潜在类别及其随时间变化的特点与影响因素.方法 采用便利抽样方法,选取2021年8月—2022年12月在哈尔滨医科大学附属第二医院心脏康复科PCI术后患者430例作为研究对象,其中有17例失访,最终413例完成了1年随访.在Ⅰ期心脏康复结束时(T1),采用一般人口学资料调查表、PCI术后患者治疗依从性问卷、冠心病健康信念量表(CHD-HBS)、简易疾病感知问卷(BIPQ)、患者健康抑郁量表-9项(PHQ-9)、广泛性焦虑量表(GAD-7)、家庭亲密度与适应性量表(FACES)、慢性病资源调查量表(CIRS)对患者进行调查.在Ⅱ期心脏康复结束时(T2)、Ⅲ期心脏康复结束时(T3)就PCI术后患者治疗依从性问卷内容对患者进行一对一随访.使用潜在类别模型确定模型数目并分组,比较不同时间点各组人数占比;比较不同时间点PCI术后患者心脏康复依从性潜在转变概率并分析其影响因素.结果 考虑整体类别数目一致性,确定最佳潜在类别模型数目为2.使用程度命名法将模型1命名为部分依从组,模型2命名为全面依从组;部分依从组T1、T2、T3人数占比分别为56.42%、61.02%和70.00%,全面依从组T1、T2、T3人数占比分别为43.58%、38.98%和30.00%.T1~T2、T2~T3、T1~T3全面依从组仍处于原潜在类别的概率分别为78.03%、81.26%、71.15%,转变到部分依从组的概率分别为21.97%、18.74%、28.85%;T1~T2部分依从组仍处于原潜在类别的概率为91.54%,转变为全面依从组的概率为8.46%;T2~T3、T1~T3部分依从组仍处于原潜在类别的概率均为100%.T1~T2年龄(χ²=26.186,P<0.001)、职业状态(χ²=18.02,P<0.001)、吸烟史(χ²=4.381,P=0.036)、饮酒史(χ²=4.91,P=0.027)、BMI(χ²=7.567,P=0.023)、既往病史个数(χ²=14.526,P=0.013)、CHD-HBS评分(t=23.191,P<0.001)、BIPQ评分(t=11.628,P<0.001)、抑郁(χ²=51.488,P<0.001)、焦虑(χ²=37.725,P<0.001)、FACES评分(t=28.309,P<0.001)和CIRS评分(t=33.579,P<0.001)是全面依从组转变为部分依从组的相关影响因素;T2~T3文化程度(χ²=4.609,P=0.019)、CHD-HBS评分(t=6.175,P<0.001)、抑郁(χ²=4.651,P=0.031)、焦虑(χ²=3.901,P=0.048)、FACES评分(t=4.037,P<0.001)和CIRS评分(t=5.829,P<0.001)是全面依从组转变为部分依从组的相关影响因素;T1~T3年龄(χ²=24.503,P<0.001)、职业状态(χ²=20.475,P<0.001)、CHD-HBS评分(t=3.577,P=0.040)、BIPQ评分(t=2.084,P<0.001)及CIRS评分(t=3.704,P<0.001)是全面依从组转变为部分依从组的相关影响因素;T1~T2职业状态(χ²=3.147,P=0.016)、医疗费用支付方式(χ²=0.299,P=0.037)是部分依从组转变为全面依从组的相关影响因素.T1~T2全面依从组转变为部分依从组的主要因素有职业状态为在职(OR=4.352,P=0.029)、CHD-HBS评分(OR=0.931,P=0.021)和BI-PQ评分(OR=1.091,P=0.025);T2~T3全面依从组转变为部分依从组的主要影响因素有文化程度低于高中(OR=6.598,P=0.011;OR=6.273,P=0.048)、CHD-HBS评分(OR=0.919,P=0.004)和FACES评分(OR=0.900,P=0.017);T1~T3全面依从组转变为部分依从组的主要影响因素有职业状态为在职(OR=3.581,P=0.024)和BIPQ评分(OR=1.072,P=0.035);T1~T2影响部分依从组转变为全面依从组的主要影响因素是医疗费用支付方式为医保(OR=2.818,P=0.043).结论 PCI术后患者心脏康复依从性存在异质性,潜在类别转变分析揭示了全面依从组与部分依从组之间的转变规律及其影响因素.
Objective To analyze the latent classes of cardiac rehabilitation adherence in patients after percutaneous coronary intervention(PCI)and the characteristics of their changes over time and influencing factors.Methods A convenience sampling method was used to select 430 PCI patients from the cardiac rehabilitation department of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Harbin Medical University between August 2021 and December 2022 as the study subjects.Seventeen patients were lost to follow-up,and 413 patients completed the 1-year follow-up.At the end of Phase I cardiac rehabilitation(T1),surveys were conducted using general demographic questionnaire,the PCI Patient Treatment Adherence Questionnaire,the Coronary Heart Disease Health Belief Scale(CHD-HBS),the Brief Illness Perception Questionnaire(BIPQ),the Patient Health Questionnaire-Depression Scale 9-item(PHQ-9),the Generalized Anxiety Disorder Scale 7-item(GAD-7),the Family Adaptability and Cohesion Evaluation Scale(FACES),and the Chronic Illness Resources Survey(CIRS).At the end of Phase Ⅱ(T2)and Phase Ⅲ(T3),one-on-one follow-up interviews were conducted based on the PCI Patient Treatment Adherence Questionnaire.Latent class analysis was used to determine the optimal number of models and groupings,and the proportions of each group at different time points were compared.Latent transition proba-bilities of cardiac rehabilitation adherence were compared,and their influencing factors were analyzed.Results The optimal num-ber of latent class models was determined to be 2 based on overall category consistency.Two models were named using the level-based naming method:Model 1 was named the partial adherence group,and Model 2 was named the full adherence group.The pro-portions of patients in the partial adherence group at T1,T2,and T3 were 56.42%,61.02%,and 70.00%,respectively,while the pro-portions of patients in the full adherence group at T1,T2,and T3 were 43.58%,38.98%,and 30.00%,respectively.From T1 to T2,T2 to T3,and T1 to T3,the probability of the full adherence group remaining in the original latent class was 78.03%,81.26%,and 71.15%,respectively,with the probability of transitioning to the partial adherence group being 21.97%,18.74%,and 28.85%,respec-tively.For the partial adherence group,the probability of remaining in the original latent class from T1 to T2 was 91.54%,with a probability of transitioning to the full adherence group of 8.46%.From T2 to T3 and T1 to T3,the probability of the partial adher-ence group remaining in the original latent class were both 100%.From T1 to T2,the influencing factors for the transition from full adherence to partial adherence included age(χ²=26.186,P<0.001),employment status(χ²=18.02,P<0.001),smoking history(χ²=4.381,P=0.036),alcohol consumption history(χ²=4.91,P=0.027),BMI(χ²=7.567,P=0.023),number of prior medical conditions(χ²=14.526,P=0.013),CHD-HBS score(t=23.191,P<0.001),BIPQ score(t=11.628,P<0.001),depression(χ²=51.488,P<0.001),anxiety(χ²=37.725,P<0.001),FACES score(t=28.309,P<0.001),and CIRS score(t=33.579,P<0.001).From T2 to T3,influencing factors included education level(χ²=4.609,P=0.019),CHD-HBS score(t=6.175,P<0.001),depression(χ²=4.651,P=0.031),anxiety(χ²=3.901,P=0.048),FACES score(t=4.037,P<0.001),and CIRS score(t=5.829,P<0.001).From T1 to T3,influencing factors in-cluded age(χ²=24.503,P<0.001),employment status(χ²=20.475,P<0.001),CHD-HBS score(t=3.577,P=0.040),BIPQ score(t=2.084,P<0.001),and CIRS score(t=3.704,P<0.001).From T1 to T2,employment status(χ²=3.147,P=0.016)and medical cost pay-ment method(χ²=0.299,P=0.037)were identified as influencing factors for the transition from partial adherence to full adherence.The main influencing factors for the transition from full adherence to partial adherence from T1 to T2 included employment status(OR=4.352,P=0.029),CHD-HBS score(OR=0.931,P=0.021),and BIPQ score(OR=1.091,P=0.025).The main influencing factors for the transition from full adherence to partial adherence from T2 to T3 included education level below high school(OR=6.598,P=0.011;OR=6.273,P=0.048),CHD-HBS score(OR=0.919,P=0.004),and FACES score(OR=0.900,P=0.017).The key influencing factors for the transition from full adherence to partial adherence from T1 to T3 included employment status(OR=3.581,P=0.024)and BIPQ score(OR=1.072,P=0.035).The main influencing factor for the transition from partial adherence to full adherence from T1 to T2 was the medical cost payment method being covered by insurance(OR=2.818,P=0.043).Conclusion Cardiac rehabilita-tion adherence in post-PCI patients exhibits heterogeneity,and latent class transition analysis reveals the transition patterns and influ-encing factors between the full and partial adherence groups.
柴卓;陈轶琳;张子琛;巩雪;张悦;韩永奎
哈尔滨医科大学护理学院,黑龙江 大庆 163319||河津市人民医院,山西 运城 043300哈尔滨医科大学附属第二医院,黑龙江 哈尔滨 150001哈尔滨医科大学护理学院,黑龙江 大庆 163319哈尔滨医科大学护理学院,黑龙江 大庆 163319哈尔滨医科大学护理学院,黑龙江 大庆 163319哈尔滨医科大学护理学院,黑龙江 大庆 163319
心脏康复经皮冠状动脉介入治疗依从性潜在类别分析潜在转变分析
cardiac rehabilitationpercutaneous coronary interventionadherencelatent class analysislatent transition analy-sis
《康复学报》 2026 (1)
16-29,14
国家自然科学基金青年基金项目(72004048)
评论