中华书局本《全唐五代词·词调索引》订正OA
Corrections to the"Index of Ci Tune Titles(词调索引)"in the Zhonghua Book Company Edition of Complete Ci Poetry of the Tang and Five Dynasties(全唐五代词)
曾昭岷等人编撰的《全唐五代词》是目前学界通行最广、影响最大的唐五代词全集.该书所附《全唐五代词·词调索引》一种,为治词尤其是治词调、词谱之学提供极大方便的同时,也存在不少疏忽.一是页码有误,其中多数是相差一页,也有相差数页、数十页乃至百多页者.二是文字有误,其中不乏衍字、漏字、错字,也有未能严格遵从原编,而使用异体字.几种中,以错字为侈,致讹之由,又兼有形、音、义相近而误数种.三是体例不当,其中有页码数与首数不合,有重出之作首句有异而未作鉴别,有未区分首句与零句、残篇发端等非首句,有未区分正编与副编尤其是副编中的依托之作等.此外,还有页码误窜,词调首句相同而误分两目,词调名目重复设置,漏列首句,漏列词调等.
The Complete Ci Poetry of the Tang and Five Dynasties(全唐五代词),compiled by Zeng Zhaomin et al.,is cur-rently the most widely circulated and influential collection of Tang and Five Dynasties ci poetry in academia.The attached"Index of Ci Tune Titles(词调索引)"in this work provides great convenience for the study of ci poetry,particularly in the fields of ci tune titles and ci prosody.However,it also contains a considerable number of errors and oversights.First,there are inaccuracies in the page numbers,with most entries differing by a single page,though some are off by several pages,dozens of pages,or even over a hundred pages.Second,there are textual errors,including redundant characters,omitted characters,and incorrect charac-ters,as well as instances where the original compilation was not strictly followed,resulting in the use of variant characters.Among these,incorrect characters are the most prevalent,with errors arising from similarities in form,sound,or meaning.Third,there are issues with the stylistic conventions,such as mismatches between page numbers and the number of entries,fail-ure to distinguish between works with different opening lines that are listed repeatedly,confusion between opening lines and non-opening lines like fragmented phrases or incomplete sentences,and failure to differentiate between the main compilation and sup-plementary sections,particularly the attributed works in the latter.Additionally,there are misplaced page numbers,erroneous separation of entries for ci tunes with identical opening lines,redundant listings of tune titles,omitted opening lines,and omitted ci tune titles.
张培阳
南阳师范学院 文学院,河南 南阳 473061
社会科学
《全唐五代词》词调索引页码错字体例
Complete Ci Poetry of the Tang and Five Dynasties(全唐五代词)"Index of Ci Tune Titles"(词调索引)page numbertextual errorstylistic convention
《南都学坛》 2026 (1)
58-66,9
国家社会科学基金一般项目"敦煌词词谱整理与研究"(21BZW008).
评论